Authors: Deborah A. Phillips, Jane Hutchison, Anne Martin, Sherri Castle, Anna D. Johnson.

Article: First do no harm: How teachers support or undermine children's self-regulation.

Publication: Early Childhood Research Quarterly (Elsevier). Volume 59, Pages 172-185 2022 | DOI: 10.1016/j.ecresq.2021.12.001


Preschoolers’ self-regulation development across the pre-k year was negatively associated with exposure to more disapproving and punitive teacher behaviors.
Negative teacher behaviors were predictive over and above the role of global quality ratings.
Children with poor regulation skills at pre-K entry showed modest evidence of being especially susceptible to harmful teacher behavior.
Quality assessments need to attend separately to supportive and harmful teacher behaviors.


Growing dissatisfaction with high-stakes uses of global early childhood classroom quality assessments has motivated efforts to identify more specific features of teacher-child interactions that support developmental growth. The current study seeks to identify specific, observable teacher behaviors that, over and above such global assessments, either promote or compromise gains in self-regulation skills across the pre-kindergarten (pre-k) year. We looked specifically at teachers’ scaffolding of peer interaction, frequency of behavior disapprovals, and reliance on punitive behavior management strategies. We also examined whether children’s fall self-regulation scores moderated associations between these teacher behaviors and children’s self-regulation development over the pre-k year. The sample consisted of 1020 low-income 4-year-olds enrolled in a “mixed-delivery” (various program auspices and locations) pre-k program in Tulsa, Oklahoma. Controlling for global pre-k quality, children whose teachers relied to a larger extent on disapproving and punitive behavior management strategies exhibited smaller gains in self-regulation across multiple assessment methods. Modest evidence emerged in support of moderation by initial self-regulation skills. These findings point to the feasibility of identifying practical, observable, and specific teacher behaviors that affect early development and to the need for quality improvement efforts that include an explicit focus on eliminating problematic teacher behaviors.

Tagged as: early childhood education, invalidation, and self-regulation


Deborah A. Phillips, Jane Hutchison, Anne Martin, Sherri Castle, Anna D. Johnson,First do no harm: How teachers support or undermine children’s self-regulation, Early Childhood Research Quarterly, Volume 59, 2022, Pages 172-185

Leave a public question or comment:

If you need personal help or assistance please use our contact forms instead.

All comments are moderated. Comments that are not relevant to the page topic or which contain identifiable personal information will be removed.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *